Trying to go green with your packaging? Choosing the right mailer can be tricky. There are so many options out there — compostable, recyclable, reusable — it’s hard to know what’s best for your business.
This quick guide breaks it all down. Here’s a side-by-side eco mailer comparison to help you pick the best sustainable shipping packaging for your needs.
1. Compostable Mailers
What they’re made of:
Cornstarch, PLA, PBAT, or kraft paper.
Good for:
Clothing, books, soft items.
👍 Pros:
-
Breaks down naturally
-
Lightweight
-
Plastic-free
👎 Cons:
-
May need industrial composting
-
Can’t be recycled
💡 Look for:
Certified labels like BPI or TÜV Austria.
2. Recycled Kraft Paper Mailers
What they’re made of:
Recycled paper or cardboard.
Good for:
Apparel, books, documents.
👍 Pros:
-
Recyclable
-
Minimalist look
-
Easy to customize
👎 Cons:
-
Not water-resistant
-
Not strong for heavy items
3. Reusable Mailers
What they’re made of:
Woven fabric or thick recycled plastic.
Good for:
Subscriptions, premium orders, returns.
👍 Pros:
-
Used multiple times
-
High-end feel
-
Cuts long-term costs
👎 Cons:
-
Expensive upfront
-
Needs a return system
4. Recyclable Poly Mailers (PCR)
What they’re made of:
Recycled plastics like HDPE or LDPE.
Good for:
Lightweight items, water-sensitive goods.
👍 Pros:
-
Waterproof
-
Tear-resistant
-
Lower impact than virgin plastic
👎 Cons:
-
Not curbside recyclable
-
Still plastic-based
5. Padded Paper Mailers
What they’re made of:
Paper with built-in padding (no bubble wrap).
Good for:
Books, beauty products, fragile items.
👍 Pros:
-
Recyclable
-
No plastic
-
Protective
👎 Cons:
-
Bulkier
-
Slightly heavier for shipping
Final Word
There’s no “perfect” mailer — just the one that works best for your product and goals. Whether you want compostable, recyclable, or reusable, there’s a better option than plastic.
Need help deciding? Direct Source Procurement offers all types of sustainable mailers — and we’ll help you pick the right one for your brand.
