Trying to go green with your packaging? Choosing the right mailer can be tricky. There are so many options out there — compostable, recyclable, reusable — it’s hard to know what’s best for your business.
Which Eco Mailer Is Best for Your Business?
This quick guide breaks it all down. Here’s a side-by-side eco mailer comparison to help you pick the best sustainable shipping packaging for your needs.
1. What Are Compostable Mailers and When Should You Use Them?
What they’re made of:
Cornstarch, PLA, PBAT, or kraft paper.
Good for:
Clothing, books, soft items.
Pros:
-
Breaks down naturally
-
Lightweight
-
Plastic-free
Cons:
-
May need industrial composting
-
Can’t be recycled
Look for:
Certified labels like BPI or TÜV Austria.
2. Why Choose Recycled Kraft Paper Mailers?
What they’re made of:
Recycled paper or cardboard.
Good for:
Apparel, books, documents.
Pros:
-
Recyclable
-
Minimalist look
-
Easy to customize
Cons:
-
Not water-resistant
-
Not strong for heavy items
3. How Do Reusable Mailers Work for Brands?
What they’re made of:
Woven fabric or thick recycled plastic.
Good for:
Subscriptions, premium orders, returns.
Pros:
-
Used multiple times
-
High-end feel
-
Cuts long-term costs
Cons:
-
Expensive upfront
-
Needs a return system
4. Are Recyclable Poly Mailers Really Sustainable?
What they’re made of:
Recycled plastics like HDPE or LDPE.
Good for:
Lightweight items, water-sensitive goods.
Pros:
-
Waterproof
-
Tear-resistant
-
Lower impact than virgin plastic
Cons:
-
Not curbside recyclable
-
Still plastic-based
5. What Makes Padded Paper Mailers a Better Option?
What they’re made of:
Paper with built-in padding (no bubble wrap).
Good for:
Books, beauty products, fragile items.
Pros:
-
Recyclable
-
No plastic
-
Protective
Cons:
-
Bulkier
-
Slightly heavier for shipping
Final Word
There’s no “perfect” mailer, just the one that works best for your product and goals. Whether you want compostable, recyclable, or reusable, there’s a better option than plastic.
Need help deciding? Book a call with our team today. Direct Source Procurement offers all types of sustainable mailers and we’ll help you pick the right one for your brand.
FAQs
-
Which type of mailer is most sustainable?
Compostable and reusable mailers reduce long-term impact, while recycled paper mailers are the most widely recyclable. -
Are compostable mailers better than recyclable ones?
Compostable mailers break down naturally, while recyclable mailers can be reused in existing recycling systems. The best choice depends on your disposal infrastructure. -
Do reusable mailers really save money?
Yes. While upfront costs are higher, they can be used multiple times, making them ideal for subscriptions and premium products. -
Can recycled poly mailers be recycled again?
Some can, but often not curbside. They usually require drop-off recycling programs. -
What is the best eco mailer for fragile items?
Padded paper mailers provide protection without plastic and are fully recyclable.
